Comparing and contrasting fitzgeralds the great gatsby and williams a streetcar named desire

Ashley Kannan Certified Educator One concurrent strand that runs between both Williams and Fitzgerald is the hollow and sometimes fraudulent nature of the American Dream. Both works show how the American Dream works for some and not for others. Those who find themselves on the negative side of this ledger experience rather harsh and brutal realities.

Comparing and contrasting fitzgeralds the great gatsby and williams a streetcar named desire

These three can be compared on several points: As depicted in the play, Willy is shown to be a very poor and ineffective salesman. He has difficulty in paying for the bills, the car, and the insurance, among others.

To make his situations worse, he always surrounds himself with delusions to make him believe that is indeed living the American Dream. He also sees his sons, who, in reality are failures in their own respects, as equally likeable and budding businessmen.

In other words, it can then be deduced that Willy has a very superifical perception of the American Dream because he believes that he can attain it by banking on his self-perceived likeability.

This is epitomized by the lavish parties that he throws every Saturday night. Although, these parties were meant to attract his former lover, Daisy, Gatsby is symbolic of the significant decay of the American Dream, which is marked by the absence of moral values, greed, and the pursuit of pleasure and not hard work.

The fact that Gatsby decided to pursue Daisy, who is married to Tom, through extravagant means indicates that his desires are ill-founded and selfish. And like Willy Loman, he too finds himself in an illusion that he can win Daisy through his massive wealth.

This is highlighted by his bitter hatred of Blanche, the sister of his wife Stella. Basically, Stanley views Blanche as obsolete survivor of an aristocracy due to the wealth that she inherited from her family. Despite being Polish by blood, Stanley indicates that the only way to attain the American Dream is through hard work.

People from Poland are Poles, not Polacks. Meaning to say, Stanley is able to full embrace his American citizenship and in effect, the American Dream. He rejects the notion of inheriting wealth and is satisfied with his average social-status. Furthermore, Willy, Gatsby, and Stanley, also have comparable points in terns of family relationships and their perception of reality.

Willy has the most strained relationship with his family among three characters. As shown in the play, as Willy surrounds himself with false realities, he rejects the love that his family gives him and constantly berates his eldest son, Biff, for being a failure.

In addition, instead of accepting the realities around him he burdens his family by being delusional. Gatsby, on the other hand, only has a close relationship with his former lover Daisy, with whom he rekindles their passion.

Comparing and contrasting fitzgeralds the great gatsby and williams a streetcar named desire

In the context of modern society, their relationship is illegal as Daisy is married to another man. As a result, he, like Willy, fails to recognize the true essence of the American Dream and is unable to accept the reality that Daisy does not feel the same way about her.

Comparing and contrasting fitzgeralds the great gatsby and williams a streetcar named desire

Finally, Stanley can be viewed as the character with the most healthy relationship with his family among the three. As shown in the play, he is very passionate about his wife and loyal to his friends. However, it is revealed towards the end of the story that he only pursues earthly desires such as sex, drinking, and gambling.

Another major issue with him is that he possesses animal-like behavior and that he cannot accept the aristocratic yet tragic past that his sister-in-law Blance had, which led him to torment her.

Meaning to say, like the other characters, he too has difficulty accepting reality. Over-all, Willy, Gatsby, and Stanley are similar in the sense that they have immense difficulty in the acknowledging and accepting the realities presented to them. They also have significantly contrasting views of the American Dream as each one pursues different objectives in life: Willy pursues his delusions, Gatsby chases forbidden love through wealth, and Stanley lavishes in sex, gambling, and drinking.

The Project Gutenburg Australia. Retrieved May 25, from http: Death of a Salesman. Reed Business Information, Inc. A Streetcar Named Desire. New Directions Publishing Corporation.In the play A Street Car Named Desire, Tennessee Williams displays the idea of the American dream within his characters.

The American dream is the idea that any man or woman, who works hard for a living, will have a good life. Comparison of characters in “Death of A Salesman,” “The Great Gatsby,” and “A Streetcar Named Desire” A Comparison of characters in “Death of A Salesman,” “The Great Gatsby,” and “A Streetcar Named Desire”.

Degeneration of Women in The Great Gatsby and A Streetcar Named Desire. Degeneration of Women in The Great Gatsby and A Streetcar Named Desire The men they are influenced by and, often, married to, and the circumstances in which they live and work dictate the women’s characters and personalities.

Tennessee Williams. A streetcar named desire: Contrasting the play with the movie production - Ebook written by Michael Grawe. Read this book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read Tennessee Williams.

A streetcar named desire: Contrasting 1/5(1). A Comparison of characters in “Death of A Salesman,” “The Great Gatsby,” and “A Streetcar Named Desire” Three stories that have characters who possess various similarities and differences are Arthur Miller’s “Death of A Salesman,” F - Comparison of characters in “Death of A Salesman,” “The Great Gatsby,” and “A.

Degeneration of Women in The Great Gatsby and A Streetcar Named Desire. Degeneration of Women in The Great Gatsby and A Streetcar Named Desire The men they are influenced by and, often, married to, and the circumstances in which they live and work dictate the women’s characters and personalities.

Tennessee Williams: A Streetcar Named Desire | Essay Example